1913 Intel

International Conflict, Western World Threats and Geopolitical Intelligence

greyimg

The Myth of Moderate Islam

Posted by Matt in June 16th, 2008

Supporting moderation in all things Islamic may seem like a no-brainer, but woe betide the policymaker who tries to turn a plausible idea into a workable strategy.

Of all the cures commonly proposed for the many ailments afflicting the Middle East, there is one tonic nearly everyone seems to agree on: boosting moderate Islam.

But this belief is dead wrong. Not only is it impossible to agree on a working definition of the word “moderate,” but there is scant evidence that extremists really do moderate once they assume power.

Read More…

My Comment:

A careful reading of the Koran shows that it is the extremists that more closely follow the Koran than moderates.

Published in Islam, , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Map for Beirut, Lebanon

[Countries link to CIA Factbook. States link to Wikipedia.]


Flickr Tags: Moderate, Islam







YouTube Related Videos for Tags: Moderate, Islam



Sayed Mustafa Qazwini - Moderate Islam
A series of motivational lectures during the holy ten nights of Muharram presented by Sayed Mustafa Qazwini. These were presented during the nights in which we mourn for Aba Abdillah Al-Hussain (AS), the grandson of the Prophet (PBUH&HF), who was brutally mudered along with his family by the opressive tyrant Yazid. This is the 2nd night of Muharram.
Tags: ashura, cyc, haidaria, haraka, hussain, imam, Islam, islamic, karbala, martyr, muslim, shia, sunni
Re: The Moderate Muslim Myth
http://www.ObsessionTheMovie.com A disturbing sequence of clips from the movie "Obsession - Radical Islam's War Against the West". Click the link to view the trailer and buy the movie. http://www.gisburne.com Don't judge Islam from the small number of moderate Muslims you may have encountered quietly going about their business in the West. Judge Islam from the Muslims in Muslim countries, where the culture of indoctrination and hatred of the West is woven into the fabric of society. Islam is not a religion of peace. These are not 'radical' views - these are the views of entire Middle Eastern countries, and these clips and more like them are shown every day on TV in those countries. If kids who are only just able to walk can call Jews 'apes and pigs', or young girls want to tell Bush...
Tags: Allah, atheism, atheist, cruel, Gisburne2000, god, Islam, Islamic, Koran, Mohammed, Muhammad, Muslim, Qur'an, Quran, religion
To the Moderate Muslim: Infidel Observations of islam
What I think the real problem is with islam. Music: The Frays, "How to Save a Life"
Tags: analysis, commentary, denial, hadith, infidel, intolerance, islam, jihad, koran, moderate, muslim, observations, quran, violence
Moderate Islam in The Netherlands?: A Mixed Picture - 1 of 4
This documentary aired on the Dutch TV channel "VPRO" in 2005. It shows a Dutch journalist looking for moderate Islam in the Netherlands. He visits two Muslim communities. On the one hand, there's the Surinamese Muslims in Amsterdam who present themselves as mainstream, moderate Muslims, but who follow Pakistani mullahs. On the other hand, there's the Ahmadiyya Muslims in The Hague, who although liberal and progressive to Western eyes, are to this day still considered to be non-muslims, i.e. apostates. Link to the online documentary: http://www.vpro.nl/programma/tegenlicht/artikelen/media/21450031/
Tags: ahmad, ahmadi, ahmadiyya, apostate, fundamentalism, ghulam, holland, islam, moderate, muslim, netherlands, religion, sharia, taibah
Hamas terrorists blame moderate Islam and "silent arabs" for Israel's retaliation
Hamas calls the killing of the terrorists "a massacre"... all the while Hamas broke the cease-fire, provoked an Israeli counter-strike by sending rockets and missiles over to Israel indiscriminately... that is the islamofascist/leftist agenda, to harass the bourgeois West until it abdicates and "submits" to the "poor" Third World supremacists. This is a war, the left are traitors and the third world radicals are out to kill and enslave us all.
Tags: beck, cnn, conservative, coulter, fox, global, god, hannity, ingraham, liberal, limbaugh, military, nbc, news, o'reilly, olbermann, on, patriots, republican, savage, terror, traitors, war
Moderate Islam in The Netherlands?: A Mixed Picture - 2 of 4
This documentary aired on the Dutch TV channel "VPRO" in 2005. It shows a Dutch journalist looking for moderate Islam in the Netherlands. He visits two Muslim communities. On the one hand, there's the Surinamese Muslims in Amsterdam who present themselves as mainstream, moderate Muslims, but who follow Pakistani mullahs. On the other hand, there's the Ahmadiyya Muslims in The Hague, who although liberal and progressive to Western eyes, are to this day still considered to be non-muslims, i.e. apostates. Link to the online documentary: http://www.vpro.nl/programma/tegenlicht/artikelen/media/21450031/
Tags: ahmad, ahmadi, ahmadiyya, apostate, fundamentalism, ghulam, holland, islam, moderate, muslim, netherlands, religion, sharia, taibah
END THE ISLAMIC OCCUPATION OF HINDU LANDS FROM AFGHANISTAN TO INDONESIA - THERE IS NO MODERATE ISLAM 1 OF 2
HINDUISM ONCE DOMINATED IRAN TO INDONESIA THROUGH THOUGHT AND PHILOSOPHY ALONE. Hinduism is the predominant religion[1] of the Indian subcontinent. Hinduism is often referred to as Sanātana Dharma, a Sanskrit phrase meaning "the eternal law", by its practitioners.[2] Hindu beliefs vary widely, with concepts of God and/or gods ranging from pantheism, monotheism and polytheism, with Vishnu and Shiva being the most popular deities. Other notable characteristics include a belief in reincarnation and karma, as well as personal duty, or dharma. Among its roots is the historical Vedic religion of Iron Age India, and as such Hinduism is often stated to be the "oldest religious tradition" or "oldest living major tradition."[3][4][5][6] It is formed of diverse traditions and types and has no...
Tags: ASSAM, BANGLADESH, BJP, ELECTION, GENOCIDE, HINDU, HISTORY, INDIA, INDUS, ISI, ISLAM, ISRAEL, JESUS, KASHMIR, KRISHNA, MUSLIM, PAKISTAN, RSS, TALIBAN, TERROR, UK, US, VALLEY
The Search of the Moderate Muslim.By Ali Sina (FFI)
PLEASE READ: http://www.faithfreedom.org/ Article Link (The Search of the Moderate Muslim.) http://www.faithfreedom.org/oped/sina31107s.htm full version: http://www.faithfreedom.org/oped/sina31107.htm FFI Forum (english) http://www.faithfreedom.org/forum.htm Faith Freedom International (FFI) is an Internet website that is critical of Islam. FFI identifies itself as "a grassroots worldwide movement of ex-Muslims and all those who are concerned about the rise of the Islamic threat". According to the website, FFI was founded by an Iranian ex-Muslim residing in Canada, going by the pseudonym of "Ali Sina." More information:http://www.faithfreedom.org/
Tags: ali, Ex-Muslims, faithfreedom, FFI, islam, moderate, muslim, sina
Myth of the Moderate Muslim Majority 1
300+ Subscribers also, thanks guys and gals. Pt:2 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PtZbVlL57Fk A good video, check it out. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BXDoEm47q60 All music by Ministers Of Dub: www.ministersofdub.co.uk
Tags: Islam, Moderates, Muslim, Myth, Snitch, Subscribers, Terrorism
So where is moderate Islam?
If there is "moderate Islam", where are its voices? None of this video is very original, I'm afraid; I'm merely echoing some sentiments aired - and to be honest, much more eloquently too - by others here. I'm jumping on the bandwagon here, to add my voice to the chorus, so to speak. I tried my best to be as calm and measured as possible whilst making this video, in the hope that by doing that I'll provoke something other than a knee-jerk reaction. I'm not interested in people posting third party evidence and arguments that moderate Islam exists. Prove it by posting an unequivocal condemnation of violence and hate speech perpetrated in the name of your religion. I also see little point in people posting such videos or comments if they are apostates or secularised non-practicing...
Tags: islam, moderate
Moderate Muslim Evangelist Mulla Zalim Nalayak Fools Around: why non muslims dont have equal rights
Here we see zakir na(la)yak making a mincemeat of logic. He explains why in islam non muslims dont have equal rights. You can not see a better justification for fascism in islam and for lack of humanism towards non-believers. Any Religion as we know involves belief. It is OK as long as belief is voluntary and does not involve insulting and asserting as lies other belief systems, a crime that islam and church are guilty of. Here zakir makes use of his belief in islam to argue the nonsense that his belief in islam gives the right for muslims to be intolerant towards other faiths. NOTE: THIS IS THE POSITION OF SO CALLED MODERATE MUSLIMS LIVING IN SECULAR INDIA ENJOYING ALL THE RIGHTS. IT MUST THEREFORE BE UNDERSTOOD THAT MODERATE ISLAM IS AN OXYMORON. We Hindus have been historically...
Tags: abab, arabia, cartoon, church, deceit, denmark, europe, france, germany, hindi, hindu, india, indian, islam, israel, jehad, jiziya, kafir, kingdom, liar, mulla, muslim, naik, pakistan, saudi, states, sweden, terror, turkey, united, urdu, zakir
NO MODERATE ISLAM - REAL MUSLIMS ARE JIHADIS THE REST SHOULD LEAVE ISLAM OR BE BRANDED TERRORIST SUPPORTERS
DON'T BELIEVE THE ISLAMIC PROPAGANDA!!!!! ISLAM IS NOT A RELIGION OF PEACE OR TOLERANCE. ISLAM HAS A CONSISTENT HISTORY OF PERSECUTING AND MURDERING NON-MUSLIMS. ISLAM WANTS TO ELIMINATE ALL OTHER RELIGIONS AT ITS CORE, SO THERE CAN NEVER BE A MODERATE ISLAM.
Tags: BANGLADESH, BJP, ELECTION, GENOCIDE, HINDU, HISTORY, INDIA, INDUS, ISI, ISLAM, ISRAEL, KASHMIR, MUSLIM, PAKISTAN, RSS, TALIBAN, TERROR, UK, US, VALLEY
The Moderate Muslim Myth (Snow3585)
CORRECTION: I meant Chairman Mao. Not Pol Pot.
Tags: AGAINST, ASS, HATE, MY, UNITED
Moderate Islam in The Netherlands?: A Mixed Picture - 4 of 4
This documentary aired on the Dutch TV channel "VPRO" in 2005. It shows a Dutch journalist looking for moderate Islam in the Netherlands. He visits two Muslim communities. On the one hand, there's the Surinamese Muslims in Amsterdam who present themselves as mainstream, moderate Muslims, but who follow Pakistani mullahs. On the other hand, there's the Ahmadiyya Muslims in The Hague, who although liberal and progressive to Western eyes, are to this day still considered to be non-muslims, i.e. apostates. Link to the online documentary: http://www.vpro.nl/programma/tegenlicht/artikelen/media/21450031/
Tags: ahmad, ahmadi, ahmadiyya, apostate, fundamentalism, ghulam, holland, islam, moderate, muslim, netherlands, religion, sharia, taibah
Moderate Muslims Intimidated in Canada 1/2
Aired on the CBC's "The National" on March 6 2007, this report addresses the threats and intimidation moderate Canadian Muslims must compose with in speaking out against religious fanaticism.
Tags: Canada, Islamism, Moderates, Muslims, Threats
(Hindi) Zalim Nalayak Moderate Muslim Evangelist Mulla Fools Around
Here we see islamic scholar dr. zakir naik. He explains in greater detail what the concept of of choice in religion that koranic ayat (2:234, 2:256) seemingly suggest. Scholars of islam explain this in the light of Seerah (hadis/sunnath)- the context and the sequence in which koranic ayats were divulged including ayat 4:137. (Non muslims if they want to understand islam need to go through entire seerah and koran) Zakir, scholar of islam highlights that there is no choice in islam. Choice is to the extent of following islam; that is no choice. Any Religion as we know involves belief. It is OK as long as belief is voluntary and does not involve insulting and asserting as lies other belief systems, a crime that islam and church are guilty of. Naik is a congenital liar and uses deceit...
Tags: 234, 2:234, advani, arab, arabia, ayat, bjp, cartoon, church, deceit, denmark, europe, france, gandhi, germany, hindi, hindu, india, indian, islam, israel, jehad, jiziya, kafir, kingdom, liar, mahatma, maino, manmohan, modi, mulla, muslim, naik, pakistan, patil, rahul, rss, saudi, shivraj, singh, sonia, states, sura, sweden, terror, turkey, united, urdu, verse, zakir
Can Moderate Islam Win Over Islamic Extremists?
Excerpt from The Defining Moment Television Talk Show interview with Ibrahim Naeem, Islamic Chaplain at the Veterans Administration Excerpt from The Defining Moment Television Talk Show interview with Ibrahim Naeem, Islamic Chaplin at the Veterans Administration Hospital in Westwood, California. Hosted by Bret Moss. http://www.definingmoment.tv
Tags: Extemists, Islam, Islamic, Jihad, Moderate, Terror, Terrorism, War
Moderate Muslims Intimidated in Canada 2/2
Aired on the CBC's "The National" on March 6 2007, this report addresses the threats and intimidation moderate Canadian Muslims must compose with in speaking out against religious fanaticism.
Tags: Canada, Islamism, Moderates, Muslims, Threats
Re: The Moderate Muslim Myth (Snow3585)
I know, my camera is awful.
Tags: amazing, athiest, Benazir, Bhutto, Extremism, Islam, Terrorism, TheAmazingAthiest
Moderate islam, political correctness gone mad?
moderate islam, political correctness gone mad
Tags: abuse, child, hadith, hajab, hijab., islam, koran, mohammed, Muhammad, Muhammed, muslim, muslims, paedophilia



1 user Responded In This Post

Follow-up this post comment rss or leave a trackback
mygif
2949. revengeBeslan said,
September 17th, 2008 at 3:48 am

Is there ‘moderate’ apartheid, or ‘moderate’ nazism ? Can a thoroughly discriminatory, hateful and genocidal cult, religion or ideology have ‘moderate’ members? Have we misunderstood nazism, was it in effect a different culture enriching the cultural diversity, misunderstood and “hijacked by some extremists” ? Were there ‘moderate nazi’s’ that held ‘moderately’ anti-semitic views? What would constitute a ‘moderate’ muslim? Someone who thinks only some rape victims should be stonded, and only some gays strung up ? I fail to understand what people mean when they speek of “moderate islam”.

Ads




Ads



Ads


Ads


Ads


Ads



Social Feeds

Topics Search

Main Translator

French

German version

Spanish version

Italian version

Main Topics

Top Stories

My Friends & Network

Pages

Main Links

June 2008
M T W T F S S
« May   Jul »
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  

Main Archives


Main Topics